Medicare Advantage Plans Too Often Deny Care and Claims: What to Do About It

Your health, longevity, and medical costs are some of the most difficult to predict aspects of financial planning. Insurance is supposed to alleviate some of the unpredictability of the financial outlay. Unfortunately, a recent report from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has found that Medicare Advantage plans have often denied care for procedures that should be covered by the insurance. And, the are not paying all eligible claims.

The federal government’s audit of Medicare Advantage Plans found evidence of “widespread and persistent problems related to inappropriate denials of services and payment.”

What is a Medicare Advantage Plan?

Medicare Advantage Plans are private alternatives to to Medicare. These plans are often cheaper with a greater range of benefits than traditional Medicare coverage from the government.

About 28 million people have a Medicare Advantage plan, doubling over the last decade.

Medicare Advantage insurers are paid a fixed amount per patient by the federal government. The report concludes that the fixed payment agreement provides, “the potential incentive for insurers to deny access to services and payment in an attempt to increase their profits.”

As an online commenter wrote, “they are disadvantage plans. They are effectively an HMO, and like in an HMO, the sponsor maximizes profit by minimizing care.”

What Care is Being Denied or Inappropriately Delayed by Medicare Advantage Plans?

While many people insured with all kinds of Medicare programs are happy with the coverage and the availability of services, the government report revealed serious problems.

The fed’s analysis found that in 13% of the cases where care was denied, the service was actually medically necessary.

The most frequent denials were for MRIs and CT scans.

Long waits for approvals are also problematic.

Medicare Advantage Plans Are Also Refusing to Pay

The report also found that Medicare Advantage plans refused to pay about 18% of claims that the auditors deemed legitimate.

What is Being Done to Correct the Situation?

Medicare officials said in a statement that they are reviewing the findings to determine the appropriate next steps, and that plans found to have repeated violations will be subject to increasing penalties.

4 Tips for Dealing with Medicare Advantage

1. Choose Your Medicare Coverage Carefully

First things first, it is critically important to understand your options for Medicare coverage and to select the right plan for you and your healthcare needs. Furthermore, you should be prepared to re-evaluate your coverage annually.

2. Appeal Denials for Care and Denials of Claims

It is your health and you need to advocate for yourself. If your doctor is recommending a procedure and insurance is denying it, start asking questions. Get second opinions. Appeal the decisions.

Medicare provides a video and tips for your appeal.

3. Budget Adequately for Out of Pocket Healthcare Costs in Retirement

According Fidelity Investments, a 65-year old couple retired in 2021 can expect to spend $300,000 in out of pocket health care and medical expenses throughout retirement. And, that value does not include long term care which is not covered by Medicare.

The NewRetirement Planner can help you estimate your healthcare costs.

  • Get a personalized estimate for all out of pocket Medicare expenses based on your age, health status, the type of coverage you want, and your location.
  • Explore ways to cover long term care.
  • See your annual healthcare costs in charts and how they rise near your longevity.

4. Explore Ways to Cut Health Costs

From Health Savings Accounts to using services from a dental school, explore 12 ways to save on retirement health costs.

NewRetirement Planner

Do it yourself retirement planning: easy, comprehensive, reliable

NewRetirement Planner

Take financial wellness into your own hands and do it yourself retirement planning: easy, comprehensive, reliable.

Share this post:

Keep Reading

All Posts

12 Surprising Ways to Save on Retirement Health Care Costs

Out of pocket retirement health care costs can be outrageous. Use these 12 surprising tips for a healthier and wealthier retirement.

November 24, 2021
Medicare open enrollment Insurance

Medicare Open Enrollment: Why You Need to Assess Your Insurance Annually and 13 Tips for Getting Great Coverage

It’s 2024 Medicare Open Enrollment time. Here are 13 tips for getting great coverage and lowering medical costs.

October 19, 2023
how much does long term care insurance cost Insurance

How Much Does Long Term Care Insurance Cost? Is It Worth It?

Find real answers about long term care insurance costs, what to look out for and who benefits. Plus, alternative ways to cover these costs.

October 11, 2021