Nobel Prize Winner Robert Merton Explains Why Retirement Planning Should Focus on Income, Not Savings

Figuring out how much income you need during retirement and formulating a retirement income plan is the most important aspect of financial planning. Don’t believe me? Well, the theory is advanced by Robert C. Merton, recipient of the 1997 Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences and Distinguished Professor of Finance at the MIT Sloan School of Management. (Hear him on The NewRetirement Podcast here.)

Robert Merton retirement income plan

Income Need is the Most Important Financial Planning Metric

Merton believes that the most important aspect of retirement planning is to estimate your retirement income and insure that it is adequate to cover your projected retirement spending.

He rejects the focus on net worth and savings formulas without first understanding spending needs and how to turn assets into income. As he said on the podcast, “Overwhelmingly, I’m trying to make the case that the thing that matters for retirement is the amount of income you get and not how big your pot is. Those are very different.”

Why? People naturally think in terms of income

Merton posits that focusing on what you will be spending in retirement and translating that into how much income you will need is a more approachable and meaningful way to think about retirement planning.Framing your retirement needs in terms of income is more understandable than focusing on a big number, especially without translating how that big number gets applied to the number of months or years in your lifetime.

He gave 2 examples in the podcast to illustrate his point:

  • What’s it take to live in a nice little town? Merton said, “If I can visit you in your hometown and I said, ‘Hey, this is a nice town. I’d like to move here.’ Then, I looked at how you’re living and I said, ‘Well, I like the way you’re living. What would it take for me to live in your town like you?’ I doubt you’d say to me, ‘You need $3,637,550 in the bank.'””I think you’d say, ‘Well, if you want to live like me here, you have to be earning about so much a year, right?’ That’s how people would say. ‘You got to earn about that amount, you can live like me.’”
  • Social Security is defined by monthly income – not a lump sum: Merton gives another example of why thinking about income is easier than a understanding a big pot of money. He said, “I’ll give you another example: Social Security around the world. When you retire, what do they give you? What do they tell you they have? Do they tell you, you have a pot of money accumulated? No. They tell you, they will pay you so much per month for the rest of your life, and they will adjust it for inflation, right? Once again, an income concept.”

If Retirement Income is the Important Metric, Why Do So Many People Worry About Retirement Savings and Rates of Return?

When pension plans were more common, it was easy to stay focused on retirement income. Pensions are usually paid out as a monthly paycheck for your lifetime. And, if you ask someone what their pension is worth they will usually reply with an income figure: “two-thirds of my final salary,”

However, as we have evolved away from pensions toward individuals being responsible for retirement savings, the metrics we typically use for retirement planning success evolved to: 

  • Savings rate
  • Savings value
  • Rates of return on savings
  • Net worth

So, even though your primary retirement concern might be having sufficient income in retirement to live comfortably, the metrics you use to track financial success (savings rate, savings value, rates of return on savings and net worth) are divorced from your goal.

And, the risk and return variables that drive investment decisions are not being measured in units that correspond to savers’ retirement income goals and their likelihood of meeting them.

A Framework for Retirement Income

In his article, “The Crisis in Retirement Planning,” published in the Harvard Business Review, Merton outlines a retirement-focused framework that divides income needs into three categories – minimum guaranteed income, conservatively flexible income, and desired extra income. He also defines how to invest money for each category.

Category 1: Minimum Guaranteed Income

When creating a retirement income plan, you first want to identify your baseline income needs. How much income is absolutely necessary for you and your household? How much income MUST you have to cover your necessities?

  • Not sure how much income you need? Use the Budgeter in the NewRetirement Planner to project both your discretionary and mandatory expenses in retirement.

Guarantee your retirement income for mandatory expenses

To cover your mandatory expenses (housing, food, healthcare, and everything else you deem necessary), you want to guarantee adequate inflation protected income – for life.

“It’s important for people to start figuring out what income they will have that is inflation-protected and guaranteed for the rest of someone’s life. This will help protect a retiree from longevity risk, interest rate fluctuations, and inflation,” writes Merton.

Retirement income that is guaranteed for life includes Social Security along with defined-benefit pensions. But there are other ways to achieve more income in this category.

“To increase the amount of guaranteed income above and beyond those benefits, the pensioner would have to buy an inflation-protected life annuity from a highly rated insurance company,” says Merton.

Lifetime income annuities offer guaranteed payments for the rest of someone’s life. For example, let’s say a 60-year-old male purchases a $150,000 annuity today with 3% inflation protection. If he were to opt to start receiving payouts in 5 years, he would get around $700 a month for the rest of his life. (Try your own calculation with NewRetirement’s Lifetime Annuity Calculator or as a scenario in the NewRetirement Planner.)

However, annuities can be inflexible investments and don’t allow for liquidity. Nor are they the most efficient investment — you aren’t going to get rich “investing” in an annuity. In fact, they are technically an insurance product.

This is why you would only want to put money into an annuity to cover the most necessary expenses. Having your needs covered can provide peace of mind.

Category 2: Conservatively Flexible Income

The next step in creating a retirement income plan is to look at a second category of retirement expenses – money to cover costs that are not strictly mandatory but that you would really like to afford.

Invest safely for money you would like, but not necessarily need, to spend

“People who are uncomfortable with annuitizing their entire retirement portfolio should consider trading off some — but not all — of their guaranteed future income for alternatives offering more flexibility,” Merton advises.

A portfolio of U.S. Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) can serve as a “more flexible but still relatively safe” alternative to annuities, he says. TIPs offer a periodic payout of inflation-protected income for a fixed period of time, called a “maturity.”

Portfolio interest income from the securities is combined with principal at each bond’s maturity to create income payments, resulting in no remaining capital once the payout period ends.

“There are two advantages to this type of conservative additional income relative to guaranteed income,” says Merton. “Because the savings can be held in liquid [U.S. Treasury] assets, they are available in whole or in part to the participant at any time, for medical emergencies or other lump sum expenditures.”

Category 3: Desired Extra Income

Finally, you want to identify the nice to have expenses (again, the Budgeter in the NewRetirement Planner can help you with this). Invest funds for discretionary expenses in accordance with your values and risk tolerance.

“People with defined-contribution retirement plans will typically find that their targeted mix of guaranteed and conservative incomes, in combination with personal assets such as their house, bank accounts, and savings, is enough to meet their retirement goals,” says Merton.

These individuals may be comfortable allocating all of their defined contribution accumulation for investments in financial products such as annuities and bond funds for additional guaranteed and conservative incomes.

“But some participants may find that their anticipated total income and assets will not be enough to finance the level of retirement income they desire,” he writes. “In that case they may wish to accept lower income now (that is, increase savings) or invest a portion of their [defined contribution] accumulations in risky assets that hold out the possibility of earning sufficient returns to permit achieving the desired higher retirement income.”

Summary of Merton’s Retirement Income Plan

Merton’s retirement income plan is basically a bucket strategy that allocates your savings according to spending needs. He recommends that:

  • What you must spend should be covered by guaranteed income. This is income that will be there no matter what happens in the financial markets or how long you live. It should be inflation protected and guaranteed for life. (Social Security, some pensions, and inflation protected lifetime annuities fit in this category.)
  • What you would like to spend doesn’t necessarily need to be covered with guaranteed income. However, it should be invested with minimal risks. Furthermore, your draw down plan should be well established. This income might come from conservative investments like bonds and treasuries.
  • Discretionary –nice to have – spending can be invested with more risk.

Achieving all three categories of income takes careful planning. The NewRetirement Planner can help you define how much you will need and when. And, you can plan for different types of income streams to meet your various spending needs.

NewRetirement Planner

Do it yourself retirement planning: easy, comprehensive, reliable

NewRetirement Planner

Take financial wellness into your own hands and do it yourself retirement planning: easy, comprehensive, reliable.

Share this post:

Keep Reading

All Posts
retirement bucket strategy Retirement Savings and Investments

Is a Retirement Bucket Strategy Right for You and Your Money? (And, How to Calculate)

Is a retirement bucket strategy right for you? Learn how to calculate your buckets and model them in your financial plan.

May 23, 2024
retirement expenses Budgeting & Spending

9 Tips for Estimating Retirement Expenses: You Need to Get this Right!

If you want a secure retirement, you need to go about estimating retirement expenses. Get 9 great tips for succeeding at this difficult task.

January 31, 2024
average retirement income 2021 Retirement Income

Average Retirement Income 2021: How Do You Compare?

How are you going to pay for retirement? How is everyone else doing it? What is the average retirement income for 2021? Has it changed a lot from past years with the pandemic? Are you anywhere close to average? 2020 was a devastating year for the finances of many households. And surprisingly, it was also…

February 10, 2021